ISLAMABAD, The dissident note written by Justice Qazi Faez Isa in Prime Minister Development Fund case has been issued.
Justice Qazi Faez Isa has said in his 28 pages dissident note that the reply from Prime Minister (PM) runs contrary to the constitution. The matter was wrapped up unexpectedly rather than seeing it in line with the constitution. The end of the case was surprising. A decision is not valid unless all the judges of bench sign it. The Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) gave illegal decision. Giving decision against judge of Supreme Court (SC) instead of investigating the matter related to PM development funds is illegal act. CJP leveled allegations but he did not give solid evidence. The CJP should have given evidence before leveling the charges of partiality against the SC judge. The Attorney General (AG) leveled allegation against the judge instead of explaining the matter of development funds. CJP should have given the decision as per law but he issued illegal decision. The illegal decision by CJP has no validity.
He further said in the dissident note that PM asked to provide development funds to members of assembly before Senate polls. The government and opposition both are saying about the matter of sale and purchase of votes. The AG instead of making investigation tried to make the judge complainant. The order cannot be legal unless it is signed by all the judges.
